A Jarring Punishment 1 and 2

By SuperEvil
superevil7@protonmail.com

Copyright 2025 by SuperEvil, all rights reserved

[15,248 words]

A Jarring Punishment

Based on ”The Punishment Jar” by Hooked6, and written with permission.

Synopsis 
This story is based off the fantastic story by Hooked6 called ”The Punishment Jar”, where Billy is made to pick a slip of paper containing a punishment from a jar when he's misbehaving. Two conniving girls, Mary Beth and Billy's sister Katie, take control of the jar when they realize they can replace the slips with punishments of their own. Humiliating punishments. I would recommend reading that story before starting this one.

This story begins pretty much right where that story left off. Mary Beth is riding high, thinking she's fooled everyone, the parents into believing Billy and the boys are responsible for switching the slips in the jar, and the boys into giving her control over what punishments will be used on them for a month. But when the truth starts coming out, Mary Beth and her co-conspirators find out they are in for a jarring punishment of their own.



Chapter 1

Mary Beth Parker was practically floating as she walked into the Burns house. She'd just pulled off the greatest trick ever - getting the boys to agree that she should be in charge of deciding what went into their punishment jar for the next month! It all started when their neighbors, Billy Anderson and his little sister Katie, came to stay with her and her mom while their parents went on vacation. Mary Beth had spotted this ceramic jar that Billy brought with him and asked Katie what it was. Katie had explained that it was his punishment jar. Whenever Billy got in trouble, instead of being given a normal punishment, he had to pick a random slip from the jar. Some punishments were just boring chores, but others were more embarrassing. That's when Mary Beth got her big idea.

Mary Beth and Katie got together and came up with a sneaky plan. They decided to take out all the original punishment slips and replace them with their own ideas. Ideas that were way more embarrassing and humiliating than the slips Billy's mother had put in the jar, and ones that would get the boy naked! To their surprise, Mary Beth's mom actually fell for their ruse! She even made Billy stay bare for an entire day as a punishment because of one of the fake slips they had put in the jar. Mary Beth thought it was hilarious that her mom was playing along, and Katie couldn't believe how much fun this was turning out to be.

But Mary Beth didn't realize that her mom was on to her sneaky plan! Before Mary Beth knew what was happening, she found herself trapped by one of her own tricks! Mary Beth, and her best friend Carrie Burns, who the moms thought was helping her with the plans, were both forced to go to a younger relative's birthday party without any clothes on, much to the joy of Billy, and the other boys at the party.

Mary Beth was cunning, however. She got together with Carrie and Katie, and they cooked up some sneaky revenge. They decided to blame everything on the boys - Billy, his friends Chester Carter and Carl Burns, and that high school jock Edward Franks, who had made fun of their punishment at the party. The girls were so good at lying that they actually convinced all the parents that it was the boys who were messing with the punishment jar all along! The parents laid their own trap for the boys because of that, with a little push from the girls, giving the boys a punishment of having to stand outside naked for three whole hours while holding signs above their heads saying "I'm being punished."

While the boys were out there, totally embarrassed and exposed, Mary Beth made them a deal. She told them she would convince the parents to let them come inside early and avoid more people seeing them, but only if they agreed to something tricky. And that's how Mary Beth got exactly what she wanted - the boys all agreed to let her be in charge of their punishment jar for a whole entire month!

With all the excitement, more girls had shown up to see the boys getting punished! Sue Ellen, who was in Billy's class at school and who Edward had a big crush on, had come along with two of her friends. There was Louise, another high schooler from Mary Beth's class, and her sister Grace, who was Katie's age. The girls were having the best time watching the naked boys while they were forced to hold up their embarrassing signs. Even when Mrs. Burns called the boys inside after Mary Beth made her deal, the girls weren't done having fun yet. Carrie invited all the new girls to come inside with them, so they could keep teasing the boys some more.

"Dad, can we get dressed now?" Edward grumbled, shifting his feet on the carpet. All the moms had herded them right into the middle of the Burns' living room, and even though he was the oldest boy, everyone could see he was the smallest one down there, which made him super embarrassed. He couldn't stand how all the girls were staring at him with those big smiles on their faces. All Edward wanted to do was get his clothes back on and pretend this whole day never happened!

Mary Beth's face lit up with a big grin. "You know, the punishment never actually said how long the boys should stay undressed for," she said, sounding all helpful. The boys started fidgeting and looking really uncomfortable when she said that. Mary Beth thought it was hilarious how they couldn't stay still for even a second. "I think they should stay naked for the rest of their three-hour punishment," she announced to everyone in the room, making sure to talk extra loud so all the adults could hear her. "It's only fair, right?"

Mary Beth's mom smiled, thinking she was teaching those conniving boys a lesson they'd never forget. "Thank you, Mary Beth. I agree," she said with a nod. The other adults all nodded too, happy to see the boys getting what they perceived they deserved. Mary Beth had to bite her tongue to keep from laughing out loud at how easily the parents had fallen for her plan! If only they knew that she had been the one that had started messing with the punishment jar to begin with! She looked around at the naked boys, all standing there looking so miserable, and at the girls, who were having the best time ever.

Mrs. Burns looked at the naked boys standing awkwardly in the middle of her living room. "Well, we really can't just have them standing here naked in the middle of the room for the next three hours," she said thoughtfully. "What should we do with them?"

Mary Beth's eyes sparkled with mischief. "I have some ideas," she chimed in quickly before any of the adults could speak.

"I know!" Katie offered excitedly, bouncing up and down on her toes. "Let's play house!" The youngest girl suggested, thinking it would be the most fun thing in the world to play house with a bunch of naked boys.

The boys let out a collective groan at the idea, looking at each other with wide eyes. Billy opened his mouth to protest, but he was quickly shot down by a glare from Mr. Franks.

The girls clapped their hands with glee, and Mary Beth couldn't help but feel a surge of excitement as she took charge. "Great idea, Katie! We'll definitely play house," she announced, turning to the boys with a wicked grin. "But first, you need to make us a proper play area right here in the middle of the room."

Billy and his friends exchanged nervous glances, but with all the parents watching, they knew they had no choice. They started pushing aside the coffee table and arranging chairs in a circle to create a makeshift play space. The girls sat down on the floor, giggling and whispering as they watched the naked boys work.

Once the play area was ready, Mary Beth stood up with her hands on her hips, looking like she was the queen of the castle. "Okay everyone, now it's time to assign roles," she declared dramatically. "Since I'm the oldest and obviously the prettiest girl here, I'll be the mother!" She said it with such confidence that none of the other girls even thought to argue. Mary Beth loved being in charge, and this was turning out to be the most fun day of taking charge for her ever!

"Edward, you'll obviously be the-" Mary Beth paused dramatically, letting the silence hang in the air. Everyone expected her to say "father" since he was the oldest boy, but Mary Beth had something much better in mind to get under his skin. She scanned his naked body slowly, making sure everyone was watching before delivering the punchline. "-the baby, since you have the tiniest penis of the bunch!"

Edward's face turned beet red. He couldn't believe she would say something like that in front of everyone, including the parents! The girls all burst out laughing, even some of the boys chuckled nervously. Edward tried to cover himself with his hands, but Mary Beth stopped him.

"No, no, no! Babies don't hide their privates! They're proud to show mommy what they've got!" she teased. She walked over to Edward and pulled his hands away, letting his tiny member hang in the open. Edward's face burned with embarrassment, but he knew there was nothing he could do about it. "Now, since you're the baby, you have to crawl on your hands and knees and call me mommy!"

Edward wanted to crawl into a hole and hide forever, instead of being made to crawl around on the floor. His cheeks burned with humiliation as he lowered himself to all fours, feeling the girls' eyes on him the entire time. He couldn't meet their gaze as he started to crawl, his small member and sack dangling between his legs. It was the most humbling experience of his life.

"And when you want something, you have to say 'Mommy, I'm hungry' or 'Mommy, I need changing,'" Mary Beth said with a smirk, clearly enjoying every second of tormenting the boy.

Edward just glared at her, his cheeks burning hotter than the summer pavement. He couldn't believe this was happening to him, the high school athlete who was used to being the one making fun of others. Now he was the butt of everyone's jokes, crawling around on the floor naked like a little baby while Mary Beth and all the girls laughed at him.

"What roles will the other boys play?" Carrie asked, eyeing her brother in particular.

"I think Carl will play the dog," Mary Beth announced, pointing to Carrie's twin brother. "He's always sniffing around and begging for treats, just like a dog." The girls giggled and Carl's ears burned with embarrassment. He didn't want to be the family pet, but with his mother and all the girls watching, he didn't have much of a choice. He dropped to his hands and knees, feeling the rough carpet scrape against his palms. As the youngest looking boy in the room, he was used to being teased and picked on, but this was a whole new level of humiliation.

"Chester can be Eddy's older brother, since his penis is the second biggest." Chester's eyes widened, not expecting to be singled out like that. He was always the quiet, shy one of the group, and having Mary Beth bring attention to his private parts made him want to curl up in a ball and hide. He felt all eyes in the room on him, and he could hear some of the girls whispering and giggling.

"What about Billy?" Sue Ellen asked, her eyes roaming over his naked body. None of the girls would say it out loud, but they all thought Billy was the cutest boy in the group. Even though he was blushing like crazy, Sue Ellen couldn't help but smile. She liked how he couldn't hide how embarrassed he was. Billy shifted his feet, wishing he could cover up with his hands like Edward had tried to do.

"Since Billy's so cute, he can be my husband!" Mary Beth declared, grabbing Billy's hand and pulling him closer. "That way, I get to boss him around even more!" The girls all giggled as Billy's face turned even redder, if that was even possible. He couldn't believe Mary Beth had just said that in front of everyone, especially his little sister Katie, who was sitting there with a huge grin on her face. Billy felt like he wanted to disappear, but Mary Beth had a tight grip on his hand and wasn't letting go anytime soon.

"And since husbands and wives kiss..." Mary Beth said, leaning in like she was going to kiss him right there in front of everyone! Billy panicked and pulled away, causing all the girls to burst out laughing even harder. Mary Beth just shook her head like she was disappointed in him. "Oh, Billy, you're such a boy!" she teased. "I guess you'll just have to do whatever else I tell you to do instead!"

All the grown-ups just sat there watching and laughing like they were at a comedy show! They thought this was the best way to teach the boys a lesson for what Mary Beth and Carrie had to go through at that birthday party. The moms and Mr. Franks kept nodding and smiling while the girls bossed the boys around, thinking it was totally fair for the boys to be embarrassed like this. Mrs. Parker even whispered to Mrs. Burns, "This is what they get for making our daughters go through that awful punishment!" Mr. Franks just nodded his head with a big grin, happy to see his arrogant son Edward being put in his place. None of the parents seemed to notice how much fun all the girls were having, or how miserable the boys looked. They were too busy enjoying the "payback" to realize that Mary Beth had secretly taken charge of everything now!

The girls were having so much fun playing house that they started getting a little bolder with their teasing. Mary Beth watched as Carrie snuck up behind her brother Carl while he was crawling around on all fours like a dog. She gave him a quick smack on his bare bottom, making him yelp and jump forward. His little penis and balls swung back and forth in between his legs when he jumped, which made all the girls giggle uncontrollably.

"Hey, stop that!" Carl whined, rubbing his bottom with his hand. But Carrie just giggled and did it again, harder this time. Carl let out another yelp and tried to scurry away on his hands and knees, but he couldn't move very fast down on the floor like that.

Sue Ellen saw what was happening and decided to join in on the fun. She walked over to where Edward was crawling around like a baby and gave his bottom a sharp pinch. Edward let out a surprised yell and tried to crawl away faster, but Sue Ellen was too quick for him. She kept pinching his bottom, laughing every time he jumped or yelled in response.

“Make her stop!" Edward complained to Mary Beth, his voice cracking with embarrassment.

 Mary Beth just shook her head and smiled. "You’re supposed to call me mommy, remember! Besides, babies don't tell their mommies what to do," she said sweetly. "Now keep crawling, little baby!"

The boys were completely miserable and humiliated, but none of the adults seemed to care. In fact, they were all laughing right along with the girls! The boys tried complaining to their parents, but they were just told to stop whining and accept their punishment like good boys. It was like the adults were enjoying watching the boys get picked on just as much as the girls were!

Billy was trying his best to stay away from Mary Beth and her friends, but he wasn't having much luck. Every time he turned around, one of the girls was there, ready to tease him or smack his bottom. He felt like he was being hunted, and he was starting to get really frustrated.

"Come on, Billy, play with us!" Louise said, grabbing his arm and pulling him toward the middle of the room and Mary Beth. "You're the husband, remember? You're supposed to play with your wife!"

Billy tried to pull away, but Louise was stronger than she looked. She dragged him over to where the other girls were gathered, all of them smiling at him with those mischievous grins on their faces. He knew he was in trouble, but there was nothing he could do to escape now.

"Don't worry, we won't bite," Grace said, giggling as she reached out to give his bottom a quick smack. Billy jumped in surprise, which made the girls laugh even harder. He could feel his face getting hot with embarrassment, and he wished more than anything that he could just disappear, but he knew that wasn't going to happen. He was stuck this way for at least another two hours.

Billy couldn't help noticing how all the girls kept staring at his private parts. Every time one of them smacked his bottom, he'd spin around to face them, but that's when another girl would sneak up behind him and smack his other cheek! They were smacking him on purpose, and he knew exactly why. They were doing it just to watch his penis and balls jiggle around when he moved. It made him feel so mortified, and he wished the floor would just open up and swallow him whole.

"You're not very fast, are you, Billy?" Louise teased, reaching out to give his butt another quick smack.

Billy yelped and jumped forward, his penis bouncing up and down as he did. The girls all giggled when they saw that, which made his face turn even redder. With all the girls paying so much attention to his penis, it wasn't long before the inevitable happened, and he was getting hard in front of them again!

"Look!" Louise squealed with delight. "Billy's getting all excited again!"

Billy's face got red with embarrassment as he tried to cover up with his hands, but Mary Beth quickly pulled them away. "Nope, not so fast!" she said, sounding like a teacher scolding a little kid. "Bad boy! You shouldn't let your thingy get all hard in front of a bunch of girls! Mom, look what Billy's doing!" She grabbed him by the shoulders, spinning him around so he was facing right toward her mom, Mrs. Parker.

Billy felt his heart sink as Mary Beth's mom stood up and walked over to him, her eyes zeroing in on his penis. "Billy Wayne Anderson! How dare you!" she scolded, her voice full of disapproval. "I'm very disappointed in you."

Billy felt his cheeks burn hot as he looked down at the floor, wishing he could disappear. "I'm sorry," he mumbled, his voice so quiet everyone had to lean in to hear him. He remembered what had happened the last time he got a boner in front of Mrs. Parker. She had said she would blister his butt if he ever did it again, and now his heart was beating fast with worry.

"Don't be too hard on him," Mrs. Burns said with a little laugh, putting her hand on her friend's shoulder before she could do something rash. "You know how boys are. They can't control how their little things react sometimes."

"They can't?" Both Mrs. Parker and Carrie asked at the same time. Mrs. Parker, who had only ever raised a daughter, didn't know much about how boys' bodies worked.

Mrs. Burns shook her head with a little laugh, mainly looking at her daughter Carrie, who seemed surprised by the news. "Oh no, they can't control that at all," Mrs. Burns explained. "It's like how we can't control when we get our periods." 

"Mom!" Carrie's eyes went wide, not believing she would bring up something so private that pertained to girls. She looked from her mom to Billy's hard penis and back again. The other girls, except Mary Beth, had similar looks of surprise and wonder.

"Really?" Mrs. Parker asked, raising an eyebrow. "You mean to tell me that boys can't help it when their... get hard like that?"

"That's right," Mrs. Burns nodded with a little smile, looking around at all the surprised faces in the room. "It's just something you learn when you have a son." She glanced over at her own son Carl, who was still crawling around on the floor like a dog, his face burning red. "Their little things have minds of their own sometimes, especially when there are pretty girls around!"

The girls all giggled at that, except for Carrie, who still couldn't believe her mom would say something like that in front of everyone. Mrs. Parker's eyes went wide as she looked from Billy's hard penis to Mrs. Burns and back again.

"So you're telling me that Billy can't help it?" she asked, sounding skeptical.

"Not at all," Mrs. Burns said with a laugh. "It's just a natural reaction that boys have, especially at his age. They can't control it, no matter how hard they try."

Billy's face felt like it was on fire. Having Mrs. Burns and Mrs. Parker talk about his hard-on right in front of everyone was almost more embarrassing than being naked in the first place! He wanted to cover up so badly, but Mary Beth was still holding his hands away, and he knew better than to try and cover up at this point anyway.

The girls couldn't wait to get back to their favorite game now that Billy was all excited! Louise and Grace ran over to the other boys, while Mary Beth held Billy's hands, making sure he couldn't cover himself. "Spank the boys! Spank the boys!" the girls chanted as they gathered around the naked boys, giggling and grabbing at their bottoms.

Carl tried to scurry away on his hands and knees, but Sue Ellen was just too quick for him. She gave his bare bottom another sharp smack, making his little penis and balls jiggle back and forth. With all the girls staring at him like that, he couldn't help but start getting an erection too!

Over in the corner, Chester yelped as Carrie pinched his bottom, his face turning bright red as the girls laughed at his penis getting hard like the other boys. Poor Chester just stood there, frozen in embarrassment, with his boner now sticking straight out for everyone to see!

But Billy was still their main target! With his hard penis sticking straight up, the girls loved watching it bounce around every time they spanked him. "Look at Billy's little friend dance!" Mary Beth giggled, reaching out to give his butt another smack.

Billy jumped and yelped as his hard member bounced up and down in front of everyone. The girls couldn't stop laughing at the sight, especially when Billy tried to cover himself with his hands, but Mary Beth wouldn't let him. "Nope! Bad boys don't get to hide!" she said, using the excuse of pulling his hands away to give his hard penis a quick squeeze! Billy gasped at the sudden pleasurable touch, his face burning hot, as Mary Beth let out another giggle at his reaction to her unwanted touch.

All the grown-ups were laughing now, just like they were watching a funny movie! Mrs. Burns shook her head and whispered to Mrs. Parker, "See? I told you, boys can't help it!" The girls just kept spanking away, having the best time ever watching the boys' bottoms jiggle and their private parts bounce around. The women especially thought it was hilarious to see three out of the four boys with hard penises sticking straight up in the air!

"Mrs. Parker!" Billy cried out in desperation, his eyes pleading for help. "Make them stop!"

But Mrs. Parker just shook her head and smiled. "Now, Billy, it's only fair that the girls get to have some fun with you after what you boys did to them," she said, taking a sip of her tea. "You should be a good sport about it."

"What we did to them?" Billy stopped in his tracks, turning to look at the woman like he didn't know what she was talking about. "We didn't do anything to them."

"Oh, no?" Mrs. Parker said, raising an eyebrow. "Did you boys really think you could get away with it?"

"I don't know what-" Billy started to say, but Mrs. Burns cut him off.

"We figured it out," Mrs. Burns said. "Your behavior is unacceptable. You've been caught red-handed. No use trying to deny it."

"What do you?-" Billy tried again, but this time Mrs. Parker cut him off with a raised finger. 

"That's enough out of you, young man. I'm very disappointed in you. You should be ashamed of yourself for what you did."

"What did they do, mom?" Mary Beth asked, her eyes lighting up with smugness. She couldn't believe how perfectly everything was falling into place! The grown-ups actually thought the boys were the ones who messed with the punishment jar this whole time, and now they were getting exactly what Mary Beth thought they deserved for being boys. She tried not to smile too big, but it was hard not to feel proud of herself for being so clever! She had the parents wrapped around her little finger, and she had the boys right where she wanted them, too!

"What do you think?" Mrs. Parker asked Mary Beth, although she already knew what her daughter would say. They'd talked all about this just yesterday, and Mrs. Parker was proud of her clever daughter for figuring everything out. She turned to face the boys, her hands on her hips as she got angrier by the second. "We know what you boys did! We know you replaced all the slips in the punishment jar with perverted ones that you wrote yourselves!" Mrs. Parker looked right at Billy when she said that, making sure he knew she was talking to him. "I even found the slips you put in the jar yesterday, Billy," she said, pointing her finger right at his face. Billy's eyes went wide as he realized she had found out about what he had done.

"I didn't do any such thing!" Edward spoke up, with Chester nodding along beside him.

"Don't try to deny it, boys," Mrs. Burns chimed in. "You've been caught. We've got all the proof we need. We found the original slips you tried to plant in Mary Beth’s room, and the new ones you put in the jar." She pointed a finger right at her son Carl, who was still on his hands and knees like a dog.

"I did it. I switched the slips, guys." Billy admitted, realizing that lying wouldn't get him anywhere. He hung his head in total shame. “I wanted to see the girls naked again after seeing them like that at the party. I'm sorry. I know it was wrong.”

"I did too," Carl said in a small voice, looking down at the carpet. His face got all red when everyone looked at him. He didn't want his friend Billy to take all the blame all by himself, even though he knew speaking up would get him into huge trouble. Carl had gone along with Billy's plan to switch the punishment slips, and now he was going to pay the price for it, too. "It was my fault too," he added, his voice cracking a little as he spoke.

Mrs. Burns looked at her son with disappointment in her eyes. "Carl Burns, I can't believe you would do something like this!" she said, her hands on her hips. "I thought you had more common sense than that!"

"It was all my idea, ma'am," Billy said, stepping forward, trying to look out for his friend. "I convinced Carl to do it. It's all my fault, really. I'm sorry. Don’t blame him. Blame me."

"Well, I had nothing to do with it!" Edward continued to claim his innocence. "Dad, you gotta believe me!"

"I didn't either!" Chester piped up. "Mom, please?"

Mary Beth gave a little nod to her friends. Carrie, Katie, and Sue Ellen all caught the signal. They had talked about this exact situation before - what they would do if any of the boys tried to deny being part of the punishment jar mess. It was time for their backup plan.

Just like they had planned, Carrie went first. "Mom," she said, trying to make her voice sound innocent and worried, "I heard Carl on the phone with Edward and Chester about a week ago. They were talking about some plan they had for Billy's punishment jar." She looked over at the other girls, who all nodded along like they'd heard it too.

Sue Ellen jumped right in, pointing at Edward and Chester. "And I saw those two at the library last week," she said with a big grin, looking around at everyone to make sure they were paying attention. "They said they were working on a project for summer school, but that's not what they were really doing!" Sue Ellen paused for dramatic effect, loving how all the girls and grown-ups were hanging on her every word. "They had a bunch of pages printed out," she continued, getting more excited. "And guess what? They were cutting them up with scissors into little strips! Just like the punishment slips!" Sue Ellen looked so proud of herself for remembering that detail, and all the girls nodded along like it was the most important clue ever.

Edward's face turned pale as he looked over at his dad. "Dad, that's not true! We were working on our summer school project!" he said, sounding desperate. "You can ask our teacher! We got a B on it!"

"Really?" Mrs. Franks asked, raising an eyebrow at his son. "Because Sue Ellen sounds pretty sure about what she saw. Why would you need scissors to work on a school project?" All the grown-ups were looking at Edward now, and he could feel his face getting hot with embarrassment.

"They were for the bibliography," Edward mumbled, looking down at the floor. "We needed to cut up the references..."

"Is that what you're going with?" Mary Beth asked with a little laugh. "Because it sounds like a pretty lame excuse to me."

"It's true!" Edward insisted, getting a little louder. "I'll show you the project when we get home!"

"I'd like to see that," Mr. Franks said, crossing his arms over his chest.

"I saw Billy using Mary Beth's computer last night!" Katie piped up, playing her part just like they had practiced. She bounced on her toes, making her voice extra loud, so everyone could hear her. "He printed out way more pages than I could count!"

Katie paused, looking around at all the grown-ups to make sure they were paying attention to her. She was so excited to be part of the plan! It made her feel all tingly inside, knowing she was helping to get her brother in trouble.

"I saw him cut up a bunch of slips and put them in the punishment jar. I bet he didn’t even realize I was watching," Katie giggled proudly, pointing her finger right at her brother. She couldn't help but feel a little smug, knowing that she had just helped trap him. She glanced over at Billy, whose mouth was hanging open in shock. He couldn't believe his own little sister would lie about something like this! Sure, he had put his own slips in the jar, but it was only the one time, and he had definitely never used Mary Beth's computer to make them!

Billy's eyes went wide as he looked at his little sister, who was standing there with a big grin on her face. How could she do this to him? They were siblings! They were supposed to stick together, not lie to get each other in trouble! Billy felt his cheeks burn with embarrassment as he looked from Katie to the other grown-ups, who were all staring at him with disapproval on their faces. He was in so much trouble now, and it was all because of his lying little sister!

"That's right," Mary Beth nodded, looking proud of her little accomplice. She knew Katie would come through for them! "I was wondering what Billy was up to on my computer after dinner last night. Now I know!"

"That's not true!" Billy exclaimed, his voice cracking with desperation. "I've never even touched your stupid computer! And Katie, why are you saying these things? You know, I only put the slips in the jar after you told me to!"

"You're just trying to shift the blame," Mary Beth said dismissively. "Typical Billy."

"Wait, Katie," Mrs. Parker said, looking at the girl carefully. "Are you sure you saw Billy using Mary Beth's computer last night, and putting slips in the jar?"

"Yep," Katie nodded, her eyes wide with excitement. "I saw it all! He was in Mary Beth's room, printing out the punishment slips, and then he snuck into the kitchen and put them in the jar!"

Mrs. Parker's eyes narrowed. She walked over to the kitchen counter where Billy's punishment jar was sitting, picked it up, and brought it over to Katie. With a little twist, she pulled the top off the ceramic jar and held it out in front of the young girl. "Pick one," Mrs. Parker said in a stern voice, shaking the jar slightly, so Katie could hear the paper slips rattling around inside.

Katie's eyes went wide with surprise as Mrs. Parker held the jar out to her. She looked from the jar to the woman's face, her brow furrowed in confusion. "What?" Katie asked, taking a step back. "Am I being punished??" Her voice cracked a little as she spoke, looking over at Mary Beth for help, but Mary Beth seemed to be just as confused as she was.

"We'll see about that," Mrs. Parker said, her eyebrows raising as she held the jar out again. She shook it right in Katie's face, making the slips rattle around again. Something didn't add up. Katie was looking way too excited for someone telling the truth, and Mrs. Parker knew the girls were up to something. She wasn't about to let Katie off the hook, not when she was so close to catching them in their little lie. "Pick a slip, Katie. Now."

Katie's hands shook as she reached toward the jar. Her eyes darted around the room, looking from Mary Beth to Carrie to the other girls, but none of them would meet her gaze. With a shaky breath, she pulled it out and unfolded the small piece of paper. Her face went white as she read the words out loud, her voice barely above a whisper. "Stand in the middle of the room for one hour without any bottoms. You are to keep your hands clasped behind your head the whole time."

"Billy, that's one of the punishments you wrote, correct?" Mrs. Parker asked him pointedly.

"Uh..." Billy hesitated, his mouth going dry. He didn't want to get into more trouble, but Mrs. Parker had that look in her eye that meant he better tell the truth. He knew he had to be honest, or else things would only get worse. "Yeah, that's one of the ones I wrote." He hung his head in shame, his face turning red as he realized he was going to get it now.

Instead of yelling at him, like he expected, Mrs. Parker turned her attention right back to Katie. A little smile played on her lips, like she was enjoying a game of exposing the truth. "Now Katie," she said in a sweet voice that sent shivers down the girl's spine, "I want you to look real close at that slip of paper in your hands." Katie's eyes widened as she stared at the punishment she'd just drawn, her hands trembling slightly as she held it. "Notice anything... interesting about it?" Mrs. Parker asked, raising an eyebrow as she waited for Katie to figure out what was so special about the slip.

Katie's brow furrowed in confusion as she stared at the paper. It just looked like any normal punishment slip to her, with an embarrassing punishment written on it. "Um... it's one of Billy's punishments?" Katie asked, looking up at Mrs. Parker with big eyes, hoping that was the right answer.

"Well, that's certainly true," Mrs. Parker nodded, pointing at the slip again. "But that's not what I meant. Look closer. What's different about this slip compared to the other ones you've seen?" She watched as Katie's eyes darted back and forth across the paper, her little mind racing to figure out what the woman was getting at. Katie's mouth hung open slightly as her brain tried to process what she was seeing. Then suddenly, her eyes went wide as she finally noticed it. The slip of paper she was holding was handwritten!

Mary Beth's eyes went wide when she saw the look on Katie's face. She knew exactly what was happening. Her mom had caught them in their lie! She had told Katie to lie about Billy using her computer, never having expected him to handwrite his own slips!

"Uh... it's... it's handwritten?" Katie said, her voice cracking with panic as she looked up at Mrs. Parker, who was now grinning, but with a menacing glare behind it.

"That's right, Katie," Mrs. Parker nodded, her voice dripping with satisfaction. "It looks like we have a rat in our midst," Mrs. Parker turned to look at her daughter, "doesn't it, Mary Beth?"



Chapter 2

Mrs. Parker had just caught Billy's little sister Katie in a lie. The younger girl had just explained how she had caught Billy using Mary Beth's computer to make fake slips for the punishment jar, her voice dripping with false innocence that Mrs. Parker could now see right through. The problem was, the fake slips Billy had made had been handwritten, clearly visible in his messy teenage boy scratch that didn't match anything a computer would produce. Now Mrs. Parker and the other parents were wondering why Katie and the other girls had been trying so hard to get them to believe the boys were behind the whole idea of switching out the slips to begin with. Mrs. Parker's eyes narrowed as she looked from the handwritten slip in Katie's trembling hand to Mary Beth's suddenly pale face, realizing there was much more to this story than she had first thought. The other mothers exchanged concerned glances, their smiles fading as they began to doubt the stories they had been given by the girls.

"It looks like we have a rat in our midst," Mrs. Parker turned to look at her daughter, "doesn't it, Mary Beth?"

"What?" Mary Beth said, her eyes widening as her mother's gaze locked onto her like a laser beam. She had always been a good liar, able to charm her way out of trouble with a smile and a few well-chosen words. But this time, her mother's eyes seemed to pierce right through her, seeing past her innocent act to the scheming girl beneath. "What do you mean?" she asked, trying to sound like she didn't know what her mother was talking about, but her heart was pounding in her chest, and she could feel her face starting to turn red.

"I think you know exactly what I mean," Mrs. Parker said, her voice hardening. "I think you've been lying to us. And I think you've been trying to get these boys in trouble. Isn't that right?"

Mary Beth felt her heart drop into her stomach. Her mother had figured it out. She was busted, but still, she couldn't help trying to talk her way out of it. She'd throw Katie under the bus if she had to. "Mom, I don't know what you're talking about," she started, trying to sound like she was still innocent. "Katie is the one who said Billy was using my computer to print out the slips. I never said I saw him printing anything!"

"Mary Beth, I want the truth," Mrs. Parker said, her eyes flashing with anger. "Did you and the other girls put those fake punishment slips in the jar?"

"Mom, no!" Mary Beth protested, her eyes widening with feigned shock. "I would never do something like that! You know me! Katie must have been the one to change the slips! Her brother probably made her do it!" Mary Beth crossed her arms over her chest and turned her nose up at her little friend, feeling a sense of relief wash over her. She had gotten out of trouble before, and she was sure she could do it again.

"Me??" Katie gasped, her face turning red. Tears welled up in her big eyes as she stared at her friend in disbelief. Katie couldn't believe what she was hearing. Mary Beth was supposed to be her friend, and here she was trying to shift all the blame onto her! It wasn't fair! Katie knew Mary Beth was behind everything! It had been her whole idea to begin with!

"Mary Beth is the one who told me to lie! She said it would be fun to get Billy naked!" Katie cried out, her voice cracking with emotion as tears started rolling down her cheeks. She looked desperately around the room at all the grown-ups, hoping someone would believe her.

Mary Beth's face went pale as Katie started to spill the beans. She tried to step forward and cover Katie's mouth, but Mrs. Burns stepped in between them, stopping her in her tracks. "You stay right there, young lady," Mrs. Burns said sternly. "I want to hear what Katie has to say."

"I'm sorry, Mrs. Parker!" Katie sobbed, turning to face the woman who had caught her in the lie. "I should have told the truth from the beginning! It was Mary Beth who changed the slips in the jar to begin with! She made me help her do it! She said she wanted to see Billy naked!"

Mrs. Parker's eyes narrowed as she listened to Katie's confession, her jaw clenching in anger. She turned to glare at Mary Beth, her eyes filled with disappointment and fury. "Is this true, Mary Beth?" she demanded. "Did you come up with the idea to change the punishment slips?"

Mary Beth's mouth opened and closed a few times, her eyes darting from her mother to the other girls and back again. She could feel the walls closing in around her, her lies catching up with her at last. With her heart pounding heavy in her chest, she made one last plea. "Mom, please! Billy's a liar and he's just trying to trick you again! Remember what he did to me and poor Carrie! He's the one who put fake slips in the jar, not me! Obviously, Katie helped him do it! Who are you going to believe, some silly little girl or your own daughter!?" Mary Beth's voice was desperate, her words tumbling out in a rush as she tried to shift the blame one last time.

Mrs. Parker's expression stayed cold. She'd heard one too many lies from her daughter to believe her now. "That's enough," she snapped, cutting off Mary Beth's protests. "You're the one who's been lying, Mary Beth. I know you. You've always been a troublemaker, and I can tell when you're up to something. You're not going to get away with this one. Now the next words out of your mouth better be the truth."

Mary Beth felt her heart sink. She'd been caught. There was no getting out of it now. With a heavy sigh, she finally gave in. "Fine, I did it. I changed the slips." she made a soft sob, her eyes dropping to the floor.

Mrs. Parker grabbed her daughter by the chin, making Mary Beth look her right in the eye. "How could you do this? I can't believe you'd trick your own mother like this! I asked you if you were behind all this, and you lied right to my face! You've been the one causing all the trouble from the start! Do you even understand what you did to those boys? They had to stand naked out on the street, with all their friends staring at them, making fun of them! You got Billy to take his clothes off in front of everyone, not just because you wanted to see it, but you exposed him to me, his sister, and all the other girls! You made me look like I didn't know what was going on, and you used how much I trust you to get away with it! I'm so mad at you, Mary Beth! I can't believe my own daughter would do something like this!"

Mary Beth looked at her mom, her eyes filling with tears. Her mind raced, searching for a way to talk herself out of this mess, but for once, she couldn't think of a single convincing lie. All the excuses she usually relied on felt useless now.

"Mom, please," she sobbed, her voice trembling. She tried to put on her most innocent face, the one that usually got her out of trouble, but it wasn't working this time. "I didn't mean to hurt anyone! I was just curious about boys!" Mary Beth looked around at all the faces staring at her, some angry, some disappointed, and some disgusted with her. She could feel the weight of her actions pressing down on her, and for the first time in a long time, she felt genuinely scared. "Please, don't be mad at me!" she cried out, hoping her mom would somehow understand and forgive her.

Mrs. Parker's voice got real quiet, which was scarier than when she was yelling. "Oh, honey, I'm not just mad at you," she said, her voice sounding sweet but with something mean hiding behind it. "I'm disappointed in you, and that's way worse. When I'm done with you, you'll wish I was just mad at you." Mary Beth looked down at her shoes, feeling her face get hot as her mom kept talking. "You have a lot to answer for. But first things first." Mrs. Parker turned to Billy, who was still standing there naked and on display to everyone. "I'm really sorry for what happened to you, Billy. I know I can't take back everything that's happened, but I'm going to do the best I can to make it right."

Billy stood there with his mouth open, trying to understand everything that was happening. Mary Beth had been behind the whole thing from the start? She had gotten Katie to help her change all the slips in his punishment jar just so she could see him naked? He felt sick to his stomach thinking about it. All this time he thought Mary Beth was just a girl who was pretty, if a little annoying, but she had come up with this mean plan just to embarrass him! He wanted to yell at her so bad his hands started to shake.

But then a different feeling washed over him. Mary Beth had gone through all this trouble just to see him without any clothes on? Like she really wanted to see him that way? His face got hot thinking about it. He knew he should be mad at her, and most of him was, but another part of him felt... kind of flattered? Even though it was super embarrassing that she had tricked him into getting naked in front of everyone, part of him felt good, knowing a girl like Mary Beth wanted to see his body so badly she would go to all this trouble just to do it.

"Thanks, Mrs. Parker," he said, his voice sounding a little shy, like he was still trying to understand his feelings. He didn't know what to say. Mary Beth had done something really mean to him, but at the same time, he felt kind of special. "I'm glad you figured it out. I just want to put my clothes back on and forget about the whole thing."

Mrs. Parker shook her head, a little sad smile on her face. "Oh, no, Billy, we can't just forget about it. Mary Beth needs to learn a lesson, a hard lesson," she said, her voice getting a little harder. Then she turned back to Mary Beth. "This is what's going to happen. I'm going to let Billy punish you however he sees fit. He's going to be the one who gets to decide your consequences. After he's done, we'll figure out what else to do to teach you to stop playing tricks on people."

Mary Beth's mouth fell open in shock. She couldn't believe what she was hearing! Her mom was going to let Billy, of all people, punish her? It was like her worst nightmare was coming true! "Mom, please! He's a boy! You know what he's going to do!" Mary Beth's voice cracked as she spoke, her eyes pleading with her mother for any other punishment.

"I know exactly what he'll do, and it's exactly what you deserve," Mrs. Parker said, her voice getting cold again. "You need to learn that actions have consequences, Mary Beth. And this is the only way to make sure you remember that. You made Billy do all sorts of humiliating things, so it's only fair that he gets to decide what happens to you."

Mary Beth felt like she was going to throw up. She knew Billy was probably just dying to get his revenge on her now that everything was out in the open. All the mean, perverted things she had made him do in front of his sister, the other girls, and her own mother came flooding back to her, and she realized with a sick feeling that Billy would be able to make her do any one of those same things! He could do whatever he wanted to her!

The other boys gathered around Billy, giving him suggestions on how he should punish the girl behind their ultimate humiliation. Carl and Chester both had big grins on their faces. "Make her stand naked in the middle of the room!" Carl said, a mischievous twinkle in his eye. "Give her a taste of her own medicine!"

Edward joined in, his smile getting even wider. "Yeah! And make her keep her hands behind her head, too! Like in that one slip!" he added, knowing how humiliating it had felt to be exposed that way himself.

Billy just shook his head, not really hearing what his friends were suggesting. Instead, he walked right up to Mary Beth, still completely naked in front of her, and looked her straight in the eyes. "I want to know why," he said, his voice cracking a little. "I just want to know why you did all this to me."

Mary Beth's throat tightened up. She didn't know what to say to him. It had all just seemed like a fun thing to do at the time. Now, seeing him standing there naked and looking so miserable, she was starting to feel a little sorry for him. But Mary Beth pushed those feelings away quick. No stupid boy was going to make her feel bad, and she definitely wasn't going to let one punish her if she could help it!

Mary Beth tried to act cool, tossing her hair over her shoulder like nothing was wrong. "I just wanted to see you without clothes on," she said in her most confident voice, trying to make it sound like it wasn't a big deal. "It was all just for fun, Billy. Like a game. What's the big deal anyway? You're just a boy, and boys shouldn't care if people see them naked."

Billy's face turned red. He couldn't believe she was acting like he was being dumb! "What's the big deal?" he snapped, his voice getting louder. "The big deal is that you made me do embarrassing things in front of all the girls and my own sister! And then you lied about it to everyone! I didn't think you were like this, but now I know better. I'm not going to let you get away with this, Mary Beth."

Billy looked at Mrs. Parker, seeing the angry look on her face and how she was nodding like she totally agreed with him. He decided right then that if that was the attitude Mary Beth was going to have, he was no longer going to hold back. Billy had been feeling all mixed up about what happened, but now he was just plain mad at Mary Beth. She had done all this mean stuff to him and was still acting like it was no big deal!

"Here's what's going to happen," Billy started, his voice sounding kind of angry, but also a little excited, too. He couldn't believe he was really being allowed to give the order he was about to make. "Mary Beth, you're going to strip naked, right now!"

Mary Beth's mouth dropped open, and she looked around at all the boys, who were watching her with big grins on their faces. "You can't be serious!" she cried out, her voice getting high-pitched. "I'm not a boy! I’m a girl! I have real feelings and stuff!"

"Well, too bad," Billy said, feeling a rush of power. "You made me do a lot of embarrassing things in front of everyone. Now it's your turn."

Mary Beth looked at her mom, her eyes wide and pleading. "You better do what he says," Mrs. Parker said, crossing her arms over her chest. "Or I'm sure he's going to make your punishment a lot worse than just stripping."

Mary Beth's face got hot, and she felt tears start to well up in her eyes. She couldn't believe this was happening to her! Her mom was really letting some boy tell her what to do, and everyone was just standing there, watching her and waiting for her to strip down to nothing. She took a deep breath and started to unbutton her blouse, her fingers trembling. The buttons seemed to take forever to undo, and with every one she popped open, she felt more and more exposed. Finally, her shirt was off, and she tossed it aside, revealing her white bra.

Billy's heart was beating so fast, he was sure everyone could hear it. He watched as Mary Beth's fingers shook while she unbuttoned her shirt, his eyes going wide. He couldn't believe she was really doing it! After all the mean stuff she did to him, he was finally getting to see her naked again! He had been thinking about seeing her like that again ever since the party, and now it was really happening right in front of him and all the other boys!

Mary Beth's face turned bright red as she reached behind her back and unhooked her bra, letting it fall to the floor. Her small, perky breasts were now exposed to everyone in the room. Billy felt himself getting hard as he stared at Mary Beth's bare chest. He couldn't help but notice how her little nipples and cone-shaped breasts were sticking out.

Mary Beth wanted to die of embarrassment. She couldn't believe she was being made to strip naked in front of Billy and the others once again! She remembered the feeling of being completely exposed at the birthday party, and her face burned even hotter. She kicked off her shoes and socks, and quickly undid her shorts, pushing them down and stepping out of them, leaving her in just her panties.

Billy's breath caught in his throat as he stared at Mary Beth in her panties. He knew what was coming next, and he could barely wait. He glanced over at Carl, who was staring at Mary Beth with his mouth open, his boner bouncing up and down like a dog waging his tail at a sight he liked. Edward and Chester were also hard, their eyes glued to the almost-naked girl.

Mary Beth made a sobbing sound, as she hooked her thumbs into the waistband of her panties, and pulled them down. Her bare butt and pussy were now on display for all the boys. Her face turned so red, Billy thought she might pass out from all the blood rushing to her head.

"Wow, I can't believe I'm really seeing your private parts again," Billy said with a huge grin, his eyes roaming all over Mary Beth's naked body. Mary Beth felt her face get hot as Billy kept staring at her. She hated feeling exposed like this in front of everyone. She had promised herself she would never end up naked like this again, but now that promise was broken. At least Billy and the other boys were still naked in front of her, and their penises had gotten all hard and bouncy from seeing her without clothes! She took a bit of pride in making that happen.

Billy felt his face getting hot as Mary Beth's eyes drifted down to his private parts, which were standing straight up. He shifted his feet, feeling all the girls staring at him, and wished he could cover up.

"Mrs. Parker?" Billy asked, his voice sounding kind of shaky. "Can we get our clothes back now? The other boys too?" He looked from Mary Beth's mom to the other boys, who were all still naked and standing there with their erections sticking up in the air.

Billy really wanted to put his clothes back on and forget his humiliation. Being naked in front of all the girls was super embarrassing, even if a part of him felt kind of intrigued that Mary Beth wanted to see him without clothes so badly.

Mrs. Parker gave Billy a little nod, her face looking serious. "Of course, Billy. You're in charge of Mary Beth's punishment now, not the other way around. You and your friends can get your clothes back whenever you're ready." She looked at her daughter, who was standing there naked with tears running down her face, and then back at Billy, who was still standing there with his boner pointing up at the ceiling. "You've earned the right to some modesty now, Billy. Just know you'll be right back where you are now, if you ever try to mess with the punishment jar behind our backs again."

Billy and the other boys quickly got dressed, putting on their clothes in a hurry. It felt so much better to have their private parts covered up, and not be on display in front of everyone, the girls especially.

After they finished getting dressed, the boys turned back to Mary Beth, who was still naked, her hands covering her breasts and her crotch. Her eyes darted around the room nervously, and Billy couldn't help but notice how embarrassed and vulnerable she looked.

"Now, Mary Beth, your punishment is just getting started." Billy said. He grabbed a rope from the corner of the room and walked back to Mary Beth. He started to tie her wrists together behind her back, making sure that the rope was tight enough that she couldn't wiggle free. Mary Beth's heart was pounding in her chest as she felt Billy work, her whole body shaking with fear and uncertainty about what he was going to do with her.

"Why am I the only one being punished?" she whined, trying to find a way out of her predicament. "What about Katie? She helped me with everything! Carrie and Sue Ellen too!"

"Mary Beth!" Mrs. Parker snapped, her eyes narrowing in disappointment. "You just worry about yourself! We'll deal with the other girls when we're good and ready." She crossed her arms and gave her daughter a stern look.

Carrie's face turned bright red when Mary Beth said her name. She felt her cheeks getting hot as she looked around at everyone staring at her. Mary Beth was supposed to be her friend, and here she was trying to get her in trouble too! Carrie noticed her mom giving her the stink eye from across the room, and she tried to make herself look less guilty by staring at the floor. Her heart was beating fast, and she wished she could disappear. She had never been in this much trouble before, and she was scared about what her mom would do with her.

"Carrie Burns, don't think I've forgotten about you," Mrs. Burns said, her voice getting all serious. "You helped Mary Beth with this whole mess, didn't you?"

"No, Mom, I didn't!" Carrie protested, shaking her head back and forth. "I had no idea what Mary Beth was doing!"

"I don't believe that for a second," Mrs. Burns said, putting her hands on her hips. "You and Mary Beth have been joined at the hip lately, always cooking up some kind of trouble. You better think real hard about what happens to girls who tell lies while you watch your best friend get what's coming to her."

"So, what are you going to do with Mary Beth now that you have her tied up, Billy?" Mrs. Parker asked, a slight smirk at the edge of her lips.

The other boys gathered around Billy, whispering ideas to him. "You gonna spank her?" Carl asked, grinning from ear to ear.

Edward jumped in, remembering how much he enjoyed watching Mary Beth get punished before. "Yeah, use a belt like at that dinner party!" he said, thinking about how Mary Beth had cried out in pain when she was whipped for misbehaving.

"You could let all of us spank her!" Chester added, his own voice filled with excitement. "We've all had to stand naked in the front yard, so it's only fair that we all get to punish Mary Beth too!"

Billy got a smug smile on his face, shaking his head. "No, I've got an even better idea for her. Come on, Mary Beth." He grabbed her by the arm, underneath, near her armpit, and started pulling her towards the door.

"What!? What are you DOING!?" Mary Beth cried with alarm. "NO! Please, no! Billy! Don’t you dare! You can't! I'll never do anything to any of you ever again! Please, just let me stay inside and give me a different punishment! Please, give me a spanking! Please, anything but that! I'll do whatever you want!" Mary Beth's eyes were wide with fear as she realized what Billy had in mind.

"Come on, guys!" Billy yelled, grinning from ear to ear as he pulled the naked, tied-up Mary Beth toward the door. He didn't care that she was crying and begging him to stop. "Mary Beth is going to be spending some time naked on the front lawn, just like we had to. Oh, and Carl, grab some of your permanent markers. We want to make it clear that Mary Beth here is being punished." Billy explained as he threw open the front door, letting in a bright stream of sunlight that made Mary Beth squirm with despair.

"NO! Please, Billy! You can't do this to me!" Mary Beth cried, tears streaming down her face as she struggled against Billy's grip. "My mom won't let you! She'll stop you!"

Billy just laughed, shaking his head as Mary Beth cried and tried to pull away from him. Mrs. Parker gave Billy a little wink and gestured for him to keep going, like she was proud of him for being so clever. Billy felt a rush of excitement, seeing that Mrs. Parker was on his side. "Your mom is the one who said I get to punish you, Mary Beth, and this is what I want." He looked over at Carl, who was already digging through the craft supplies on the table, making a mess as he searched for the markers. "Make sure you grab a dark color," Billy called out to him. "I want everyone to know that Mary Beth Parker is being punished for being a lying girl who likes to trick boys into getting naked, and we're gonna write that all over her naked body!"

Mary Beth's eyes got big as she heard what Billy had planned for her. Writing on her naked body was even more embarrassing than just making her stand outside naked and hold a sign! "Mom, please! You can't let him do this!" she cried out, looking over at her mom with tears in her eyes, but Mrs. Parker just stood there shaking her head, watching as Billy finally dragged her out the door.

Once they were out on the front lawn, Billy and the boys surrounded Mary Beth, holding her in place while Billy grabbed the black permanent marker from Carl. He uncapped it and started writing right below Mary Beth's tits, the ink staining her skin. "Mary Beth Parker is a mean girl who likes to trick boys into getting naked," Billy read aloud as he wrote, his handwriting messy but legible. Mary Beth's eyes got wide as she saw the words appearing on her skin. "Biggest pervert in the world!" Billy added, grinning as he wrote the last word on her tummy with a flourish.

"Hey, I have an idea," Edward piped up, a gleam in his eye. "Let's put a list on her of all the bad things she's done. That way, everyone knows exactly what she did to deserve this." The boys nodded eagerly, liking Edward's idea. He took the marker from Billy, holding the tip against her upper back. "Go ahead, Mary Beth. Tell us all the bad things you've done."

Mary Beth felt her cheeks burn with humiliation as the other boys all started to laugh and point at her. "Go on, Mary Beth, tell us," Carl said, his eyes twinkling with mischief. "What did you do to deserve this punishment?"

"Screw you guys!" Mary Beth spat, her voice dripping with venom. "I'm not gonna tell you anything!"

Edward gave her bare butt a quick smack, making her jump with surprise. "Oh, I think you will," he said, his voice full of confidence. "Because if you don't, we'll just have to make it up ourselves, and I don't think you want that, do you?" He raised an eyebrow, daring her to refuse.

Mary Beth knew she didn't have a choice. She didn't want the boys to make up some fake crimes that would make her look even worse. With a heavy sigh, she started to list off the things she had done to them. "I switched Billy's punishments in the punishment jar," she said quietly. "And I made him touch his... penis in front of my friends. And I held his penis when I was giving him that spanking the other day..." Mary Beth's voice got quieter and quieter with each admission, and the boys all looked at her with wide eyes, surprised at how honest she was being. Billy seemed both a little embarrassed, but vindicated as she made each admission.

The boys all took turns writing on Mary Beth's naked body with the black marker, making her list all the bad things she'd done to them. Each boy wanted to add their own special message to her skin. Chester and Carl each wrote a word on one of her boobs, "Liar" and "Phony" in big black letters that made Mary Beth's face turn even redder.

Edward knelt down behind her and made her bend over a little bit so he could write on her bare butt. "Needs a spanking" he wrote in his messy handwriting, making all the other boys laugh. Mary Beth felt so embarrassed with her bottom on display like that, with words written all over it!

But Billy had the naughtiest idea of all. He got down on his knees right in front of her, so he was face-to-face with her private parts! Mary Beth tried to close her legs tight, but the other boys held them open, so Billy could write whatever he wanted.

"Naughty" he wrote right above her pubic hair, making the letters big and dark. Then he wrote "girl" right across her labia lips, making Mary Beth squirm when the marker tickled her down there.

The marker felt funny against her skin, and she couldn't help making a little noise when it dragged across her most sensitive spot. She'd never had anyone touch her there before, and it felt all tingly and wrong at the same time! It was super embarrassing that Billy was touching her there, especially in front of everyone, and she could feel her face getting hotter and hotter.

"How does that feel, Mary Beth?" Billy asked with a big grin, looking up at her from between her legs.

Mary Beth didn't know what to say! Her face was so red she thought it might explode, and she could feel tears starting to well up in her eyes again. She couldn't believe Billy was writing on her most private spot, in front of everyone! It was the most humiliating thing that had ever happened to her in her whole life!

By the time the boys were through, almost every bare surface of Mary Beth's skin was covered in permanent marker. Her back, arms, and legs had all the crimes she had listed off, while her boobs and private parts were marked with the nasty words the boys had come up with to describe her.

Mary Beth couldn't believe what was happening. She was standing naked on the lawn, with her hands tied behind her back, and her body was covered in words and drawings that made her look like a complete and total pervert! And worst of all, she was going to be stuck like this until Billy decided she had been punished enough!

Inside the house, Mrs. Burns wasn't wasting any time with her daughter. "Carrie, get over here right now," she said, her voice getting that serious tone Carrie knew meant trouble. Carrie's eyes got big as she looked over at her mom. She had been hoping her mom would wait to talk to her after everyone left, but no such luck. "You better tell me the whole truth about what you did with Mary Beth," Mrs. Burns said, crossing her arms over her chest. "And if you try to lie to me, you're going to be sorry. I'll make sure you can't sit down for a whole week if I find out you're hiding anything!"

Mrs. Parker turned to Katie, her voice stern. "That goes for you too, Katie. Don't think for a second you're off the hook for your involvement in this." Katie's eyes went wide. "I'm going to be making a long distance call to your mother, and you're going to explain to her what you and Mary Beth have been up to since she's been gone." Katie's face went pale at the thought of having to explain everything to her mom over the phone, especially with Mrs. Parker standing right there, listening to every word.

Carrie swallowed hard as she watched her best friend get dragged out the front door by Billy. As the door shut behind them, she turned to her own mother, her heart pounding in her chest. "Mom, I didn't have anything to do with this!" Carrie protested, her voice getting high-pitched as she tried to convince her mom that she was innocent.

"Yes you did!" Katie exclaimed, her face red with anger. "You knew exactly what Mary Beth was doing! You helped her come up with the plan to get back at the boys, and you were laughing at them the whole time!"

"Mom, it wasn't my fault!" Carrie pleaded, tears welling up in her eyes. "I didn't help Mary Beth change the punishments! Doesn't that count for something?"

Mrs. Burns gave her a stern look. "I don't care if you didn't help her change the punishments," she said, her voice getting cold. "You knew what was going on, and you didn't do anything to stop it. You should have told an adult about the fake slips Mary Beth put in the jar as soon as you found out about them. Instead, you just stood by while the boys were humiliated. All I want to know is why?"

"Mom, that's super embarrassing to explain..." Carrie began.

"You seemed to disregard just how embarrassed those boys were, including your own brother!" Mrs. Burns snapped. "Don't you have any compassion for what they must have felt?"

"Yes..." Carrie began, feeling a tear run down her cheek. "I guess I did it because it felt exciting..." She whispered, her voice getting soft as she looked down at the floor. "It felt fun being in control and having the boys at our mercy."

Mrs. Burns just stared at her daughter in disbelief. "You did it for the thrill of having power over those boys? For your own sexual gratification?? That's sick, Carrie!"

Carrie looked at her mom with big eyes. "Mom, I'm really sorry!" she said, tears running down her face. "I know I shouldn't have done it, but it was just so much fun! I promise I'll never do anything like that again!"

"You bet you won't, because you're going to feel exactly how it was for them! Get your clothes off! You're joining Mary Beth!" Mrs. Burns ordered, her voice leaving no room for argument. Carrie's eyes got huge as she realized her mom was serious. She was going to have to take her clothes off in front of everyone? And stand outside naked with Mary Beth, too? She felt like she was going to be sick to her stomach.

"But Mom!" Carrie cried, her voice shaking. "Please! I can't do that! Everyone will see me out there!"

"I don't want to hear another word from you," Mrs. Burns said sternly, pointing toward the front door. "You're going to join Mary Beth out there and learn what humiliation feels like. Now get those clothes off before I take them off for you!"

Carrie's hands shook as she slowly reached for the bottom of her t-shirt. She could feel all the other girls staring at her, their eyes wide with shock. Even though they knew any one of them could be next, none of them could look away as Carrie started to undress.

Carrie felt her face burn with embarrassment as she pulled her shirt over her head, revealing her sizable teenage breasts in her pink bra. She hesitated for a moment, her hands shaking as she reached for the zipper on her skirt. With a deep breath, she pulled it down, letting her skirt fall to the floor and pool around her ankles, leaving her in just her bra and flowery panties. Carrie felt so exposed, standing there in just her underwear, in front of her mom and the other girls, and most shamefully, Mr. Franks! She couldn't believe this was happening to her!

Mrs. Burns crossed her arms and gave her daughter a disapproving look. "Come on, Carrie. You know what I want. Get the rest of those clothes off. I'm not letting you outside with a scrap of clothing on your body, no matter how long it takes you to undress!"

Carrie's hands were shaking as she reached behind her back to unclasp her bra. With a deep breath, she pulled it off, letting her breasts spill free, with perky pink nipples on the ends. Then, taking another breath, she slid her panties down, revealing her trimmed bush to the room. She tried to cover her private parts with her hands, her face burning with shame.

Mrs. Burns walked over and grabbed Carrie's hands, pulling them away from her crotch and chest. "I think you would know by now that you're not allowed to cover up while being punished." Carrie's eyes filled with tears as her mom pulled her arms to her sides. She couldn't believe her mom was forcing her to stand there completely naked in front of everyone, with her breasts and pubic area on full display. She felt so humiliated, like everyone could see right through her.

"Well, shall we bring her out to join Mary Beth and the boys?" Mrs. Parker asked her friend with a raised eyebrow.

"I think that's a splendid idea," Mrs. Burns said, a little smirk playing at the edge of her lips. "Let's give your daughter some company. Maybe seeing her friend suffer will make Mary Beth realize the error of her ways. Or maybe it will make her realize how she should have left well enough alone from the start."

Mrs. Burns and Mrs. Parker dragged Carrie outside by her arms. The cooler air made goosebumps pop up all over Carrie's skin. Carrie blushed as her nipples got hard when the wind blew across her bare chest. As they approached the boys and Mary Beth, they could hear them in the middle of an argument. Mary Beth's voice was high-pitched with embarrassment and anger. "No, I won't do it!!"

Billy glared at Mary Beth, his eyes narrowing like he'd just been slapped across the face. "What did you say?" he demanded, his voice cracking as he stepped closer to her.

"I said no, I won't do it!" Mary Beth repeated, her voice getting louder as she tried to stand up straight despite her hands being tied behind her back. "You can't make me! I won't ask for my own punishment jar!"

"Yes you will!" Billy shouted, his face turning red with anger.

"I said no," Mary Beth repeated. "I won't agree to having a punishment jar. You don't have anything else to hold over me. I'm already standing here naked in front of everyone, and I've been humiliated enough by your writing. When this is through, I'm going back in the house, and putting my clothes back on, and then everyone is going to forget about this in a few weeks. What else could you possibly do to me?"

Billy looked at Mary Beth, his face twisted into a grin. "Oh, I have a few ideas," he said, his voice sharp. "First of all, did you forget about all the guests you invited over? They should be showing up any minute now, right?"

Mary Beth's face turned smug at his words. "I never invited anyone," she said. "Besides Louise and her sister. I lied to you to get you to agree to my demands. There aren't any guests coming."

His face turned to disgust. "That was a real shitty thing to do! So, just another lie you told?"

"So, what are you going to do about it, huh?" Mary Beth said proudly, her chin held high despite being naked with her hands tied behind her back. "I can't believe you guys fell for that! You really thought I invited all my friends over to come see you naked? Boys are so dumb!" She looked at each of them, her eyes filled with contempt. "You're all so easy to trick! You'll probably all end up naked again by the time the day is over!"

"Mary Beth Parker!" Her mom suddenly shouted, having caught the whole exchange. "That's enough! You're acting like a spoiled, rotten brat!"

Billy looked at Mary Beth with a big grin on his face, his eyes sparkling like he had just figured out the best trick of all. All the other boys were grinning too, their faces lit up with the same mean excitement. They could tell Mary Beth was about to get what she deserved from her mom, and they couldn't wait to see it happen!

Then the boys saw them. Mrs. Parker and Mrs. Burns were walking right toward them, and they weren't alone! Walking between them was Carrie, with her face all red and her eyes looking down at the grass. And she was completely naked! Her boobs bounced up and down as she walked, and her little slit was on full display for everyone to see. The boys' grins got even bigger when they saw her, and Billy felt his penis twitching in his pants.

"Looks like somebody else is in trouble," Carl sang, as he eyed his naked sister from head to toe. Carrie looked up at her brother with her face turning beet red. She had been hoping the boys might go easier on her than they did Mary Beth, since she had not been the master mind behind everything, but the looks on their faces told her that wasn't going to happen.

Billy felt his jaw clench as he stared at Mrs. Burns, his eyes wide with anger and hurt. "Your daughter knew the whole time, Mrs. Burns, didn’t she?" he asked, his voice tight with emotion. "She knew what Mary Beth was doing to me, and she just sat by and watched it happen? She didn't even try to stop it?"

Mrs. Burns gave her daughter a disapproving look. "That's right, Billy," she said, her voice stern. "She didn't do anything to stop Mary Beth, even after she knew the truth. She just let you be humiliated in front of everyone."

Billy looked at Mrs. Burns and Mrs. Parker, his face set with determination. "Well, if that's the case, I think she deserves the same punishment that Mary Beth is getting."

"That's the reason we brought her out here." Mrs. Burns said with a nod. "We brought a couple of poster boards for you. We didn't think you should write on her body, since she wasn't the one who came up with the twisted idea. But you can make her a sign to hold above her head." Mrs. Burns handed Billy a permanent marker and a large piece of cardboard, and Billy got to work, writing "Carrie Burns is a dirty girl" on one side in big black letters. Then, he turned the board over and wrote "Who watched a boy get naked and laughed" on the other side.

Billy grabbed Carrie by the arm and pulled her over to the edge of the curb, making her stand a little ways away from Mary Beth. "Here you go," he said, shoving the cardboard sign into her hands. "Hold it up high above your head. Make sure everyone can read what a dirty girl you are."

Carrie's face turned bright red as she lifted the sign high up in the air. "I don't want to do this," she whispered, her voice trembling.

"Too bad," Billy said with a stern look for her. "You're going to stand right here until I say you can move. And remember, no covering up. I want everyone who walks or drives by to get a good look at you."

As Billy and the other boys gathered around, making sure that Carrie was positioned in the most embarrassing way possible, with her legs spread apart, and the sign held high above her head, Mrs. Parker was trying to teach Mary Beth a lesson too.

"Okay, young lady, I want you to tell me EXACTLY what you did to trick the boys today," she said, crossing her arms and glaring at Mary Beth. "Don't leave out a single detail, young lady. I want to know everything."

"I... I don't know what you mean, mom?" Mary Beth stammered, her full body trembling.

Mrs. Parker's eyes narrowed. "Don't lie to me, Mary Beth. I heard everything you were just saying. Now, you're going to tell me exactly what you did to trick the boys and how you lied to them."

Mary Beth's face turned red as a beet. "But... but I don't want to," she mumbled, her voice getting all shaky.

"Young Lady, you're going to tell me every detail, and you're going to do it right now," Mrs. Parker said sternly, her eyes fixed on Mary Beth.

"Okay, okay," Mary Beth said, her voice shaking. "I, uh, I lied to the boys and said that more girls were coming. I told them they had to agree to my demands or else they'd be naked in front of everyone."

Mrs. Parker's face turned even more serious. "And what were your demands?" she asked.

Mary Beth looked down at her feet, not wanting to say it out loud. "I made them agree to let me take control of the punishment jar in exchange for getting them out of being seen by everybody," she said quietly.

"Oh my Lord, Mary Beth! I'm so disappointed in you! You lied to us, and you lied to the boys. How could you?" Mrs. Parker asked. She looked at Billy. "I can't believe this. I'm so sorry, Billy, boys. What do you think I should do with her? Obviously I haven't raised her right."

Billy heard the woman saying his name and turned his attention away from Carrie. "I don't know." He scratched his chin as he came over. "Actually," Billy looked at Mary Beth with a gleam in his eye. "I think Mary Beth knows what her punishment should be."

"You think I'm going to say I deserve a punishment jar?" Mary Beth said, her eyes narrowing. "No way, Billy. That's not gonna happen!"

"Maybe you do," Mrs. Parker said, her voice full of disappointment. "You've been doing a lot of lying and manipulating lately. Maybe it would do you some good to have your own punishment jar." She sighed, shaking her head at her daughter's behavior. "Well, boys," Mrs. Parker continued, looking over at Billy and his friends, "we'll leave these two naughty girls in your capable hands for a bit. We have a few phone calls to make to the other parents about their daughters' behavior."

"Wait, Mom!" Mary Beth cried out, her voice cracking with panic. "Don't leave me out here like this with them!" Tears streamed down her face as she tried to pull against the rope that bound her hands, but it was too late. The screen door slammed shut behind Mrs. Parker and Mrs. Burns, leaving Mary Beth and Carrie standing naked and alone in the front yard with the boys. Their bare bottoms felt cold in the breeze, and both girls shivered, partly from the chill and partly from the fear of what might happen next. Billy and his friends gathered around them like wolves, grinning from ear to ear as they looked over the two naked girls who had caused them so much trouble. Carrie clutched her cardboard sign tighter, wishing she could just vanish, while Mary Beth tugged uselessly at the rope binding her wrists, realizing with a sick feeling that they were completely at the mercy of the boys they had humiliated just a short while before.

Mary Beth turned to look at Billy, her eyes filled with fear and anger. "This isn't fair!" she cried out, tears streaming down her face. "I don't deserve this!"

Billy just grinned wider, his smile like a knife cutting through her defenses. "That's where you're wrong, Mary Beth," he said, his voice dripping with satisfaction. "I think you're getting everything you deserve."

"You know, guys, I wonder how many phone calls we could make before their moms found out." Chester chuckled, relishing the situation the girls were now in.

Carl's face lit up with a big grin, getting exactly what his friend was thinking. "You mean, how many boys we could invite over to see these two naked before the grown-up found out?" he asked, his voice full of excitement as he looked at Mary Beth and Carrie. "I bet we could get Edward's friends to come over, and maybe some of the kids from school too!" Carl's eyes were practically sparkling at the thought of all the boys gathering around to see Mary Beth and Carrie standing there naked and embarrassed in front of everyone. He knew they would think of the girls as so weird for what they had done, and they would probably want to get a good look at the girls' naked bodies too! "Yeah," Carl continued, his voice getting more confident, "we could even tell them to bring their cameras and take pictures! That would be the best punishment of all!"

Mary Beth's eyes went wide as saucers as she heard what Carl was saying. "No!" she cried out, her voice shaking with fear. "You can't do that! You can't call your friends and let them see me like this! Please, Billy, don't let them do this!" Tears were streaming down her face as she begged and pleaded with him. "I'll do whatever you want, please!" Mary Beth cried out, her voice getting all high-pitched and desperate. "Please, Billy, don't do this to me!"

Billy just laughed, a deep, cruel laugh. "I don't know, Mary Beth," he said, his eyes gleaming with malice. "I think it would serve you right to have everyone see you like this. It's only fair after what you did to us."

Mary Beth felt her stomach drop, like she was going to be sick. "Please, Billy," she begged, her voice barely a whisper. "You can’t do that! I'll never do it again, I promise! Don't let anyone else to come over! Please, please, please!" Tears streamed down her face as she pleaded with Billy, her whole body shaking with fear and humiliation.

"Wow, you're so desperate, I bet you'd agree to having a punishment jar, and letting us punish you for a whole year just so no one else sees you like this." Billy taunted, his voice mocking her as she begged and pleaded with him.

"I will! I'll do anything you want, Billy!" Mary Beth yelled back at him, her voice breaking.

Billy doubled over in laughter at her response. He looked at the other boys, his eyes shining with glee. "Did you guys hear that? Mary Beth just agreed to take a whole year of punishments from us!" He clapped his hands together, rubbing them gleefully. "Do you really think we'd do that to you?"

"Yes," Mary Beth whimpered.

Billy just shook his head, his face getting serious. "That's the difference between you and me, Mary Beth. I wouldn't stoop to your level, and force you into some kind of twisted deal."

Mary Beth gasped, her eyes filling with fresh tears of relief. "You... you mean you're not going to call your friends to come over? Or punish me for a whole year?" she asked, her voice trembling with hope.

"Nope," Billy said, his voice firm. "I'm not going to humiliate you like that," he paused. "Not unless you give me a reason to." Mary Beth's shoulders shook as she cried harder, wondering why Billy would ever show her any kind of mercy.